Best Restaurants in Co. Mayo
Ranked by Google ratings — updated 21 October 2026
As of 21 October 2026, LocallyIrish.ie ranks 40 restaurants in Co. Mayo by customer rating. The top-rated is Restaurant Killala, with 4.9 stars from 77 Google ratings. Nevin's Newfield Inn follows with 4.8 from 1996 Google ratings.
How we rank
Each business is scored on its average rating weighted by how many ratings it has, so a handful of perfect scores cannot outrank hundreds of near-perfect ones. Reviews left on LocallyIrish.ie and the business's Google rating are counted together; the rating shown on each entry is labelled with its source. A Google rating needs at least 5 ratings to count. Businesses without enough ratings are listed separately, unranked. Paid listings cannot buy a higher position. The list refreshes hourly.
None of these businesses is on that register — clear the filter to see them all.
Restaurant Killala
Gold · 2026 Top RatedNevin's Newfield Inn
Silver · 2026 Top RatedDillon's Bar & Restaurant
Bronze · 2026 Top Rated
Sage Restaurant
Mags' Place
No.8 Tapas Bar
Billy's Pizza
The Tavern Bar & Restaurant
House of Plates
Clare Island Community Centre Anchor Bar& Bistro
Tia by the river
Punch Bowl
The Lighthouse Diner
Coveys Gastrobar
Tia
Blue Serenade Restaurant
The Ice House Restaurant
Luseas Rooftop Restaurant
Cullen's at the Cottage
Dragon Palace Chinese Takeaway
Zambrero Castlebar
Charlie's at the Towers
The Connaught Room at Ashford Castle
Gaffneys Seafood Restaurant
Moytura at the Riverside
Stone Barn Cafe
Maestro's Restaurant
King's Chinese Takeaway
The Drawing Room at Ashford Castle
Chapter Twenty Three at Kiltimagh Park Hotel
Fáilte Ireland approved
Captains Galley
Wilde's at the Lodge
Kitchen Garden Restaurant
Jackie's bar
Lydon's Bar
Apache Pizza Castlebar
Oriental Chinese Restaurant
Khan's Pizza Bar and Kebab Takeaway
The Waterfront Restaurant
The Siar Restaurant and Bar
Best restaurants by town
Best restaurants in Mayo — FAQs
What is the best restaurants in Mayo?
Restaurant Killala is currently the top-rated restaurants in Co. Mayo, with 4.9 stars from 77 Google ratings. See the full ranked list above.
How are the best restaurants in Mayo ranked?
Each business is scored on its average rating weighted by how many ratings it has, so a handful of perfect scores cannot outrank hundreds of near-perfect ones. Reviews left on LocallyIrish.ie and the business's Google rating are counted together; the rating shown on each entry is labelled with its source. A Google rating needs at least 5 ratings to count. Businesses without enough ratings are listed separately, unranked. Paid listings cannot buy a higher position. The list refreshes hourly.
How can my restaurants business rank higher in Mayo?
Encourage happy customers to leave a review on your LocallyIrish.ie listing. More high-star reviews move you up the "Best of" ranking for Co. Mayo.
⭐
Used a restaurants in Mayo?
Help others by leaving a review on their listing — it only takes a minute.
Find & Review a Business